| Ano | Vencedor | Título PT/BR | Título PT/PT | Autor(es) | Estúdio | Outros Indicados |
|---|
| 1927-1928 | Underworld | Paixão e Sangue | | Ben Hecht | Paramount | The Last Command |
| 1928-1929 | ---------- | | | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- |
| 1929-1930 | ---------- | | | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- |
| 1930-1931 | The Dawn Patrol | Patrulha da Madrugada | A Patrulha da Alvorada | John Monk Saunders | Warner Bros. | The Doorway to Hell
Laughter
The Public Enemy
Smart Money |
| 1931-1932 | The Champ | O Campeão | O Campeão | Frances Marion | MGM | The Star Witness
What Price Hollywood?
Lady and Gent |
| 1932-1933 | One Way Passage | A Única Solução | O Bilhete de Ida e Volta | Robert Lord | Warner Bros. | The Prizefighter and the Lady
Rasputin and the Empress |
| 1934 | Manhattan Melodrama | Vencido pela Lei | O Inimigo Público Número Um | Arthur Caesar | MGM | Hide-Out
The Richest Girl in the World |
| 1935 | The Scoundrel | O Energúmeno | | Ben Hecht/Charles MacArthur | Paramount | Broadway Melody of 1936
The Gay Deception |
| 1936 | The Story of Louis Pasteur | A Vida de Louis Pasteur | A Vida de Pasteur | Pierre Collings/Sheridan Gibney | Warner Bros. | San Francisco
Fury
Three Smart Girls
The Great Ziegfeld |
| 1937 | A Star Is Born | Nasce Uma Estrela | Nasceu Uma Estrela | Robert Carson/William Wellman | United Artists | Black Legion
In Old Chicago
The Life of Emile Zola
One Hundred Men and a Girl |
| 1938 | Boys Town | Com os Braços Abertos | | Dore Schary/Eleanore Griffin | MGM | Blockade
Angels with Dirty Faces
Test Pilot
Mad About Music
Alexander's Ragtime Band |
| 1939 | Mr. Smith Goes to Washington | A Mulher Faz o Homem | Peço a Palavra | Lewis R. Foster | Columbia | Young Mr. Lincoln
Bachelor Mother
Love Affair
Ninotchka |
| 1940 | Arise, My Love | Levanta-te, Meu Amor | | Benjamin Glazer/John Toldy | Paramount | Edison, the Man
The Westerner
My Favorite Wife
Comrade X |
| 1941 | Here Comes Mr. Jordan | Que Espere o Céu | O Defunto Protesta | Harry Segall | Columbia | Ball of Fire
The Lady Eve
Meet John Doe
Night Train to Munich |
| 1942 | 49th Parallel ou The Invaders | Invasão de Bárbaros | Os Invasores | Emeric Pressburger | Columbia | The Talk of the Town
The Pride of the Yankees
Yankee Doodle Dandy
Holiday Inn |
| 1943 | The Human Comedy | A Comédia Humana | | William Saroyan | MGM | Destination Tokyo
Action in the North Atlantic
The More the Merrier
Shadow of a Doubt |
| 1944 | Going My Way | O Bom Pastor | O Bom Pastor | Leo McCarey | Paramount | A Guy Named Joe
Lifeboat
None Shall Escape
The Sullivans |
| 1945 | The House on 92nd Street | A Casa da Rua 92 | A Casa da Rua 92 | Charles G. Booth | Fox | The Affairs of Susan
Objective, Burma!
A Song to Remember
A Medal for Benny |
| 1946 | Perfect Strangers | Longe dos Olhos | Férias de Casamento | Clemence Dane | MGM | The Stranger
The Strange Love of Martha Ivers
To Each His Own
The Dark Mirror |
| 1947 | Miracle on 34th Street | De Ilusão Também Se Vive | De Ilusão Também Se Vive | Valentine Davies | Fox | La Cage Aux Rossignols
It Happened on Fifth Avenue
Smash-Up, the Story of a Woman
Kiss of Death |
| 1948 | The Search | Perdidos na Tormenta | Anjos Marcados | Richard Schweizer/David Wechsler | MGM | Louisiana Story
The Naked City
The Red Shoes
Red River |
| 1949 | The Stratton Story | Sangue de Campeão | Tenacidade | Douglas Morrow | MGM | Come to the Stable
It Happens Every Spring
Sands of Iwo Jima
White Heat |
| 1950 | Panic in the Streets | Pânico nas Ruas | Pânico nas Ruas | Edna Anhalt/Edward Anhalt | Fox | The Gunfighter
When Willie Comes Marching Home
Mystery Street
Riso Amaro |
| 1951 | Seven Days to Noon | Ultimato | | James Bernard/Paul Dehn | Boulting Bros. | Here Comes the Groom
Teresa
Bullfighter and the Lady
The Frogmen |
| 1952 | The Greatest Show on Earth | O Maior Espetáculo da Terra | O Maior Espectáculo do Mundo | F. Frank/T. St.John/F. Cavett | Paramount | My Son John
The Sniper
The Narrow Margin
The Pride of St. Louis |
| 1953 | Roman Holiday | A Princesa e o Plebeu | Férias em Roma | Dalton Trumbo | Paramount | Little Fugitive
Above and Beyond
The Captain's Paradise |
| 1954 | Broken Lance | A Lança Partida | A Lança Quebrada | Philip Yordan | Fox | Pane, Amore e Fantasia
Night People
There's No Business Like Show Business
Jeux interdits |
| 1955 | Love Me or Leave Me | Ama-me ou Esquece-me | | Daniel Fuchs | MGM | Rebel Without a Cause
The Private War of Major Benson
Le Mouton à Cinq Pattes
Strategic Air Command |
| 1956 | The Brave One | Arenas Sangrentas | O Rapaz e o Touro | Dalton Trumbo | RKO | The Eddy Duchin Story
Umberto D.
Les Orgueilleux |
