Wikipedia:General sanctions/South Asian social groups

Community discussions

A 2012 community discussion at the administrators' noticeboard placed all pages about social groups, explicitly including caste associations and political parties related to India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Nepal under community discretionary sanctions.

Subsequent enforcement tended to treat this sanction more akin to the "related to X, broadly construed" wording seen in most other sanctions. A 2023 discussion at the administrators' noticeboard found no objection to formalizing existing de facto practice, expanding the sanctions' scope to pages related to South Asian social groups, broadly construed.

Remedies

Sanctions imposed cannot be undone by another administrator without approval of the sanctioning administrator or an appeal at the administrators' noticeboard. Pages may be tagged with {{Gs/talk notice|sasg}}, which can be used to indicate that articles are within the scope of these sanctions. Prior to being sanctioned, editors can be notified of these sanctions with the {{subst:Gs/alert|sasg}} template. Use the {{subst:Community sanction}} template when imposing sanctions. For blocks, use {{subst:Uw-csblock}}.

The standard set of discretionary sanctions are imposed on all pages related to social groups, broadly construed—be they castes, communities, tribes, clans, kootams, gotras, etc., and explicitly including caste associations and political parties—related to India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Nepal. This includes biographies that mention subjects' membership in such groups.

Log of administrative actions

Log blocks, topic bans or other administrative actions here. Include diff of username, action-date-time-duration etc, diffs of any evidence, administrator user name.
Admins: Please move the sanction to the bottom of the expired section once it has expired.

Active sanctions

Add the following text replacing the text in all caps with the necessary info:

User sanctions

* {{User2|USERNAME}}, TYPE OF SANCTION, DURATION, DIFF ON USERPAGE. ~~~~

Resumed after block expired and blocked for a month. Daniel Case (talk) 04:19, 11 March 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Article-specific sanctions and protections

Expired sanctions

Extended content
UserAction dateTypeScopeEnforcing adminExpiration date
Vyasan2012-05-05Topic banAll edits relating to the Nair caste across all namespacesSalvio giuliano2012-12-09
Robin klein2012-06-05Topic banAny edits, across all namespaces, relating to the following subject: Jews or Christians in India and Saint Thomas ChristiansSalvio giuliano2012-12-06
BetterIndia2012-05-18Topic banAll edits relating to any caste across all namespacesSalvio giuliano2012-08-19
Ruderow2012-06-22Topic banAny edits relating to the Kayastha caste across all namespacesSalvio giuliano2012-09-23
Vettakkorumakansnehi2012-06-25Topic banAll edits relating to the Nair caste across all namespacesThe Blade of the Northern Lights2012-12-25
Chauhan11922012-05-28Topic banAnything pertaining to social groups, across all namespacesSalvio giuliano2012-08-29
Kallarmagan2012-06-28Topic banAll edits relating to the Kallar caste across all namespacesSalvio giuliano2012-09-29
Mariraj.s2012-07-13Topic banAll edits relating to castes and ethnic/social groups across all namespacesSpacemanSpiff2012-10-13
Dcoda892012-09-08Topic banAll edits relating to any caste across all namespacesSalvio giuliano2013-03-09
Hoshigaki2012-09-22Topic banAll edits relating to any caste across all namespaces per ANI discussionThe Blade of the Northern Lights2013-03-22
CorrectKnowledge2012-09-22Topic banAll edits relating to any caste across all namespaces per ANI discussionThe Blade of the Northern Lights2013-03-22
ApostleVonColorado2012-09-22Topic banAll edits relating to any caste across all namespaces per ANI discussionThe Blade of the Northern Lights2013-03-22
Starrahul2012-10-16Topic banArticles and discussions related to Maratha, broadly construed, per this.The Blade of the Northern Lights2013-04-16
68.98.32.2502013-01-31Block, 3 daysQwyrxian2013-02-03
68.98.32.2502013-02-06Block, 2 weeks, for continuing same behavior that lead to previous sanctionQwyrxian2013-02-20
Clarkpoon2013-02-073 day block for disruptive editing on Saini.If disruptive behavior continues, a topic ban may be the necessary next step.Qwyrxian2013-02-10
Irajeevwiki2013-04-033 day blockTalk:Ezhava pursuant to ANI discussionDrmies2013-04-07
Jattnijj2013-08-161 month Block

Permalink to AN/I discussion

2over02013-09-16
Indiansociology2014-03-16topic ban (1 year)All edits relating to castes and ethnic/social groups across all namespaces2over02015-03-16
WiseWik2016-03-20Block (24 hours)Violation of topic ban.[35]Bishonen2016-03-21
Bhumihar (article)2014-05-25Semi-protectionBhumihar (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views) Due to persistent disruptive editing and non-neutral point of view editing.CallaneccIndefinite
User:Kunal gurjar2014-06-15Topic BanTopic banned [36] from editing anything related to Gurjar across all name spaces; action due to repeated BLP vios after multiple warnings.SpacemanSpiff2014-09-15
Kunal gurjar2014-6-22BlockUser:Kunal gurjar blocked 10 days with topic ban reset until end of September, for repeated and persistent breaches of topic ban [37]. Fut.Perf.Future Perfect at SunriseTen days
John811jd2014-11-21Block for disruptive editing: violations of WP:FORUM, WP:RS, etc. Discussion at ANI ongoing; perhaps an indef block will result if copyvio allegations are proven and added to the evidence.Rajput and talk pageDrmies36 hours
Shvrs2014-09-28BlockRepeated infractions of topic banBishonen3 months
Gattysandhu2015-06-283 day blockEditor blanked DS notification and continued to add unsourced material and original research to caste articles.Ponyo2015-07-01
WiseWik2016-03-09Topic ban* Any edit to Komati caste and related pages for one month anywhere on Wikipedia per this notification.BishonenOne month
Sharkslayer872018-05-01Topic banIndefinitely topic banned from making any edits to caste-related pages and discussions per this notice.Bishonen2018-12-14

See also