1990 New Zealand general election

The 1990 New Zealand general election was held on 27 October to determine the composition of the 43rd New Zealand parliament. The governing Labour Party was defeated, ending its two terms in office. The National Party, led by Jim Bolger, won a landslide victory and formed the new government.

1990 New Zealand general election

← 198727 October 19901993 →

All 97 seats in the House of Representatives
49 seats needed for a majority
 First partySecond partyThird party
 
Jim Bolger, 1990s (cropped).jpg
Mike Moore 1992 (further cropped).jpg
Jim Anderton 2000 (cropped).jpg
LeaderJim BolgerMike MooreJim Anderton
PartyNationalLabourNewLabour
Leader since26 March 19864 September 19901 April 1989
Leader's seatKing CountryChristchurch NorthSydenham
Last election40 seats, 44.02%57 seats, 47.96%New party
Seats won67291
Seat changeIncrease 27Decrease 28Increase 1
Popular vote872,358640,91594,171
Percentage47.82%35.14%5.16%
SwingIncrease 3.80%Decrease 12.82%Increase 5.16%

Results by electorate, shaded by winning margin

Prime Minister before election

Mike Moore
Labour

Subsequent Prime Minister

Jim Bolger
National

This election was the first time since 1975 that National had won the popular vote.[1][2]

Background

The Labour Party had taken office after defeating the National Party under Robert Muldoon in the 1984 election. David Lange became Prime Minister and Roger Douglas became Minister of Finance. The economic program outlined by Douglas was deeply unpopular with Labour's traditional supporters, however – deregulation, privatisation, and free trade, all opposed by the party's more left-wing members, were a key part of the Rogernomics platform. This internal dissent was off-set somewhat by new social legislation and a strong stance against nuclear weapons.

Labour was re-elected in the 1987 election with its parliamentary majority untouched, but the internal disputes continued. Eventually Lange forced Douglas to resign in December 1988, but continued destabilisation of his leadership by Douglas had weakened Lange's position such that he resigned eight months later. He was replaced as Prime Minister by Geoffrey Palmer, but Palmer failed to revive Labour's falling popularity. Several months before the election, Palmer was replaced by Mike Moore. The National Party was performing strongly – its leader, Jim Bolger, spoke repeatedly of "the Decent Society", saying that the reforms were doing significant damage to the social fabric of the country. The government was also being challenged by the NewLabour Party, founded by renegade MP Jim Anderton.

MPs retiring in 1990

Five National MPs and eleven Labour MPs intended to retire at the end of the 42nd Parliament.

PartyNameElectorate
NationalGeorge GairNorth Shore
Merv WellingtonPapakura
Ian McLeanTarawera
Venn YoungWaitotara
Derek AngusWallace
LabourGeoffrey PalmerChristchurch Central
Stan RodgerDunedin North
Anne CollinsEast Cape
Trevor YoungEastern Hutt
Roger DouglasManurewa
Philip WoollastonNelson
Colin MoyleOtara
Trevor de CleenePalmerston North
Bob TizardPanmure
Michael BassettTe Atatu
Russell MarshallWanganui

The election

The date for the 1990 election was 27 October. 2,202,157 people were registered to vote, and 85.2% of these people turned out. The number of seats being contested was 97 – this was the same as in the previous election, which had the largest number of seats for any Parliament until that point.

Summary of results

The 1990 election eventually saw a victory for the National Party, then in opposition. National won nearly half (48%) of the vote and 67 (69%) of the seats, becoming the fourth National government. This was the highest number of seats the party had ever won, either in absolute terms or as a percentage. Four new (and young) National MPs: (Bill English, Tony Ryall, Roger Sowry and Nick Smith) were called the "brat pack" by Sir Robert Muldoon (himself one of the "Young Turks" of 1960).[3]

The new Green Party gained the third-highest number of votes, but won no seats. The NewLabour Party won a single seat, due to Jim Anderton retaining the Sydenham seat he originally won as a Labour candidate.

The governing Labour Party, by contrast, suffered its worst-ever electoral defeat since it first won power in the 1935 election, winning only 29 (30%) of the seats and 35% of the vote (its lowest percentage since 1931), and losing 27 seats. Initially it appeared that twelve ministers and the Speaker had lost their seats, but Fran Wilde scraped in on special votes. Many of Labour's talented "class of 84" were sent away, though five of them, Annette King, Jim Sutton, Trevor Mallard, Richard Northey and Judy Keall, returned in 1993.[4]

The result was primarily due to intense anger at Labour and its policies (shown by it losing 12% of the vote) rather than love of National (which only increased its vote by 4%).

Detailed results

Party totals

Election results[5]
PartyCandidatesTotal votesPercentageSeats won
National97872,35847.8267
Labour97640,91535.1429
Greens71124,9156.85-
NewLabour9394,1715.161
Democrats9130,4551.67-
Social Credit6817,8970.98-
Mana Motuhake410,8690.60-
McGillicuddy Serious5910,0580.55-
Christian Heritage189,5910.53-
Minor parties and Independents7612,8630.71-
Total6741,824,09297

Votes summary

Popular Vote
National
47.82%
Labour
35.14%
Greens
6.85%
NewLabour
5.16%
Democrats
2.02%
Others
3.37%
Parliament seats
National
69.07%
Labour
29.90%
NewLabour
1.03%

Electorate results

The tables below shows the results of the 1990 general election:

Key

  National  Labour  Democrats  NewLabour  Mana Motuhake

Electorate results for the 1990 New Zealand general election
ElectorateIncumbentWinnerMajorityRunner up
General electorates
AlbanyDon McKinnon7,455June Allen
AshburtonJenny Shipley7,922Basil Moskovis
Auckland CentralRichard Prebble3,277Kathryn Hill
AvonLarry Sutherland4,250Wendy Rush
AwaruaJeff Grant4,964Heather Russell
Bay of IslandsJohn Carter5,285Bruce Raitt
BirkenheadJenny KirkIan Revell2,813Jenny Kirk
Christchurch CentralGeoffrey PalmerLianne Dalziel3,769Ross Gluer
Christchurch NorthMike Moore2,148Peter Yarrell
ClevedonWarren Kyd4,732Ann Batten
CluthaRobin Gray6,527Jeff Buchanan
CoromandelGraeme Lee6,342Margaret Hawkeswood
Dunedin NorthStan RodgerPete Hodgson2,336Gael Donoghue
Dunedin WestClive Matthewson1,779Ian McMeeking
East CapeAnne CollinsTony Ryall1,968Dianne Collins
East Coast BaysMurray McCully5,216Gary Knapp
Eastern HuttTrevor YoungPaul Swain801Rosemary Thomas
EdenRichard NortheyChristine Fletcher1,524Richard Northey
FendaltonPhilip Burdon4,993Tony Day
GisborneAllan WallbankWayne Kimber449Allan Wallbank
GlenfieldJudy KeallPeter Hilt2,958Judy Keall
Hamilton EastBill DillonTony Steel2,121Bill Dillon
Hamilton WestTrevor MallardGrant Thomas1,563Trevor Mallard
HastingsDavid ButcherJeff Whittaker728David Butcher
Hawkes BayBill SuttonMichael Laws2,895Bill Sutton
HeretaungaBill JeffriesPeter McCardle1,122Bill Jeffries
HobsonRoss Meurant6,641Howard Henry
HorowhenuaAnnette KingHamish Hancock624Annette King
InvercargillRob Munro4,137Barry Rait
Island BayElizabeth Tennet3,635Ann Nolan
KaimaiRobert Anderson8,147Gordon Dickson
KaiparaLockwood Smith8,610Wayne Sellwood
KapitiMargaret ShieldsRoger Sowry1,599Margaret Shields
King CountryJim Bolger7,274Cameron Gordon
LytteltonPeter SimpsonGail McIntosh68Peter Simpson
ManawatuDavid RobinsonHamish MacIntyre3,089David Robinson
MangereDavid Lange4,039Bryan Archer
ManurewaRoger DouglasGeorge Hawkins1,143Pat Baker
MaramaruaBill Birch7,670Charles Chauvel
MarlboroughDoug Kidd7,187Barbara Hutchinson
MatamataJohn Luxton8,501Bill Pepperell
MiramarPeter NeilsonGraeme Reeves552Peter Neilson
Mt AlbertHelen Clark1,230Larry Bellshaw
NapierGeoff Braybrooke1,265Colleen Pritchard
NelsonPhilip WoollastonJohn Blincoe636L Baigent
New LynnJonathan Hunt1,099Martyn Athol Bishop
New PlymouthHarry DuynhovenJohn Armstrong1,701Harry Duynhoven
North ShoreGeorge GairBruce Cliffe6,183Graeme Ransom
OhariuPeter Dunne783George Mathew
OnehungaFred GerbicGrahame Thorne612Fred Gerbic
OtagoWarren Cooper3,927Tony Cooke
OtaraColin MoyleTrevor Rogers1,226Taito Phillip Field
PahiatuaJohn Falloon7,689Margo Martindale
PakurangaMaurice Williamson9,086Paul Charles Grant
Palmerston NorthTrevor de CleeneSteve Maharey349Paul Sherriff
PanmureBob TizardJudith Tizard1,098Gray Bartlett
PapakuraMerv WellingtonJohn Robertson5,665James Stubbs
PapatoetoeRoss Robertson510Allan Brewster
PencarrowSonja Davies384Ray Wallace
PoriruaGraham Kelly3,453P Faulkner
RaglanSimon Upton5,442Olivia Scaletti-Longley
RangioraJim Gerard5,273Judith Alison McLachlan
RangitikeiDenis Marshall6,127Patricia Barton
RemueraDoug Graham7,368Carl Harding
RoskillPhil GoffGilbert Myles644Phil Goff
RotoruaPaul East5,270Bruce Raitt
St AlbansDavid Caygill1,560David Dumergue
St KildaMichael Cullen1,886Bruce Alexander
SelwynRuth Richardson5,441Val Elley
SydenhamJim Anderton1,443Linda Constable
TamakiRobert Muldoon7,592Malcolm Johnston
TaranakiRoger Maxwell7,867Scott Dalziel
TaraweraIan McLeanMax Bradford5,152Malcolm Moore
TasmanKen ShirleyNick Smith2,246Ken Shirley
TaurangaWinston Peters9,314Bill Delaney
Te AtatuMichael BassettBrian Neeson1,370Dan McCaffrey
TimaruMaurice McTigue3,192Gary Clarke
TitirangiRalph MaxwellMarie Hasler64Ralph Maxwell
TongariroNoel ScottIan Peters886Noel Scott
WaikaremoanaRoger McClay5,865David Davies
WaikatoRob Storey6,172George Middleton
WaipaKatherine O'Regan8,477Mark Apiata-Wade
WairarapaWyatt Creech4,141Pauline Moran
WaitakiJim SuttonAlec Neill2,905Jim Sutton
WaitotaraVenn YoungPeter Gresham7,192Dominic O'Sullivan
WallaceDerek AngusBill English8,886David Soper
WanganuiRussell MarshallCam Campion409Jill Pettis
Wellington CentralFran Wilde246Pauline Gardiner[nb 1]
West AucklandJack Elder252Laurie Wicks
West CoastKerry BurkeMargaret Moir2,611Kerry Burke
Western HuttJohn TerrisJoy Quigley700John Terris
WhangareiJohn Banks6,839Edna Tait
YaldhurstMargaret Austin42John Connelly
Māori electorates
Eastern MaoriPeter Tapsell6,844Wi Kuki Kaa
Northern MaoriBruce Gregory956Matiu Rata
Southern MaoriWhetu Tirikatene-Sullivan7,614Tikirau Stevens
Western MaoriKoro Wētere5,466Eva Rickard

Table footnotes:

Summary of seat changes

  • Electoral redistributions:
    • There was no redistribution of electoral boundaries between the 1987 and 1990 elections.
  • Seats captured:
    • By National: Birkenhead, East Cape, Eden, Gisborne, Glenfield, Hamilton East, Hamilton West, Hastings, Hawkes Bay, Heretaunga, Horowhenua, Kapiti, Lyttelton, Manawatu, Miramar, New Plymouth, Onehunga, Otara, Roskill, Tasman, Te Atatu, Titirangi, Tongariro, Waitaki, Wanganui, West Coast and Western Hutt (27 seats) were captured from Labour. Seventeen of these (Gisborne, Hamilton East, Hamilton West, Hastings, Horowhenua, Lyttelton, Manawatu, Miramar, New Plymouth, Onehunga, Otara, Roskill, Te Atatu, Titirangi, Tongariro, Wanganui & the West Coast) were one-term gains, recaptured by Labour in 1993.
  • Seats transferred from departing MPs to new MPs:
    • The seats of North Shore, Papakura, Tarawera, Waitotara and Wallace, all held by departing National MPs, were won by new National candidates.
    • The seats of Christchurch Central, Dunedin North, Eastern Hutt, Manurewa, Nelson, Palmerston North and Panmure, all held by departing Labour MPs, were won by new Labour candidates.

Post-election events

A number of local by-elections were required due to the resignation of incumbent local body politicians following their election to Parliament:

  • A by-election to the Auckland City Council was caused after Maungakiekie Ward councillor Grahame Thorne resigned his seat after he was elected MP for Onehunga, necessitating a by-election to fill the council vacancy. The by-election was won by Ken Graham with two candidates from the general election, Richard Northey (Labour candidate for Eden) and Laurie Ross (Green candidate for Onehunga), also contesting.[6]
  • A by-election to the Auckland Regional Council was caused after Panmure Ward councillor Judith Tizard resigned her seat after she was elected MP for Panmure, necessitating a by-election to fill the council vacancy. The by-election was won by Bruce Jesson with a retiring candidate at the general election, Bob Tizard (previously Labour MP for Panmure) also contesting.[7][8]
  • A by-election to the Wellington City Council was caused after Southern Ward councillor John Blincoe resigned his seat after he was elected MP for Nelson, necessitating a by-election to fill the council vacancy. The by-election was won by Margaret Bonner with two candidates from the general election, Ann Nolan (National candidate for Island Bay) and Jeff Montgomery (NewLabour candidate for Wellington Central), also contesting.[9][10][11]

Notes

References

  • Bassett, Michael (2008). Working with David: Inside the Lange Cabinet. Auckland: Hodder Moa. ISBN 978-1-86971-094-1.
  • McLeay, E. M., ed. (1991). The 1990 General Election, Perspectives on Political Change in New Zealand: Occasional Publications No 3, Department of Political Science. Wellington: Victoria University of Wellington. ISBN 0-475-11202-4.
  • Stringer, John (1990). 1990 Parliamentary Candidates for the New Zealand National Party. Wellington: New Zealand National Party.
  • Vowles, Jack; Aimer, Peter (1993). Voters' Vengeance: The 1990 Election in New Zealand and the fate of the Fourth Labour Government. Auckland: University Press. ISBN 1-86940-078-X.