Year Goalkeeper Defenders Midfielders Forwards 1996 [2] Mark Dodd , Dallas Leonel Álvarez , Dallas John Doyle , San Jose Robin Fraser , LA Galaxy Mauricio Cienfuegos , LA Galaxy Roberto Donadoni , MetroStars Marco Etcheverry , D.C. United Preki , Kansas City Carlos Valderrama , Tampa Bay Eduardo Hurtado , LA Galaxy Roy Lassiter , Tampa Bay 1997 [2] Brad Friedel , Columbus Jeff Agoos , D.C. United Thomas Dooley , Columbus Richard Gough , Kansas City Eddie Pope , D.C. United Mark Chung , Kansas City Marco Etcheverry , D.C. United (2) Preki , Kansas City (2) Carlos Valderrama , Tampa Bay (2) Ronald Cerritos , San Jose Jaime Moreno , D.C. United 1998 [2] Zach Thornton , Chicago Thomas Dooley , Columbus (2) Robin Fraser , LA Galaxy (2) Luboš Kubík , Chicago Eddie Pope , D.C. United (2) Chris Armas , Chicago Mauricio Cienfuegos , LA Galaxy (2) Marco Etcheverry , D.C. United (3) Piotr Nowak , Chicago Stern John , Columbus Cobi Jones , LA Galaxy 1999 [2] Kevin Hartman , LA Galaxy Jeff Agoos , D.C. United (2) Luboš Kubík , Chicago (2) Robin Fraser , LA Galaxy (3) Chris Armas , Chicago (2) Mauricio Cienfuegos , LA Galaxy (3) Marco Etcheverry , D.C. United (4) Eddie Lewis , San Jose Steve Ralston , Tampa Bay Jason Kreis , Dallas Jaime Moreno , D.C. United (2)2000 [2] Tony Meola , Kansas City Robin Fraser , LA Galaxy (4) Greg Vanney , LA Galaxy Peter Vermes , Kansas City Chris Armas , Chicago (3) Piotr Nowak , Chicago (2) Steve Ralston , Tampa Bay (2) Hristo Stoichkov , Chicago Carlos Valderrama , Tampa Bay (3) Mamadou Diallo , Tampa Bay Clint Mathis , MetroStars 2001 [2] Tim Howard , MetroStars Jeff Agoos , San Jose (3) Carlos Llamosa , Miami Pablo Mastroeni , Miami Greg Vanney , LA Galaxy (2) Chris Armas , Chicago (4) Piotr Nowak , Chicago (3) Preki , Miami (3) Alex Pineda Chacón , Miami Diego Serna , Miami John Spencer , Colorado 2002 [2] Tim Howard , MetroStars (2) Wade Barrett , San Jose Carlos Bocanegra , Chicago Alexi Lalas , LA Galaxy Mark Chung , Colorado (2) Ronnie Ekelund , San Jose Óscar Pareja , Dallas Steve Ralston , New England (3) Jeff Cunningham , Columbus Carlos Ruiz , LA Galaxy Taylor Twellman , New England 2003 [2] Pat Onstad , San Jose Carlos Bocanegra , Chicago (2) Ryan Nelsen , D.C. United Eddie Pope , MetroStars (3) Chris Armas , Chicago (5) DaMarcus Beasley , Chicago Mark Chung , Colorado (3) Landon Donovan , San Jose Preki , Kansas City (4) Ante Razov , Chicago John Spencer , Colorado (2)2004 [2] Joe Cannon , Colorado Jimmy Conrad , Kansas City Robin Fraser , Columbus (5) Ryan Nelsen , D.C. United (2) Eddie Pope , MetroStars (4) Eddie Gaven , MetroStars Amado Guevara , MetroStars Ronnie O'Brien , Dallas Kerry Zavagnin , Kansas City Brian Ching , San Jose Jaime Moreno , D.C. United (3)2005 [2] Pat Onstad , San Jose (2) Chris Albright , LA Galaxy Danny Califf , San Jose Jimmy Conrad , Kansas City (2) Clint Dempsey , New England Dwayne De Rosario , San Jose Christian Gómez , D.C. United Shalrie Joseph , New England Ronnie O'Brien , Dallas (2) Jaime Moreno , D.C. United (4) Taylor Twellman , New England (2)2006 [2] Troy Perkins , D.C. United Bobby Boswell , D.C. United José Burciaga Jr. , Kansas City Jimmy Conrad , Kansas City (3) Ricardo Clark , Houston Clint Dempsey , New England (2) Dwayne De Rosario , Houston (2) Christian Gómez , D.C. United (2) Justin Mapp , Chicago Jeff Cunningham , Salt Lake (2) Jaime Moreno , D.C. United (5)2007 [3] Brad Guzan , Chivas USA Jonathan Bornstein , Chivas USA Michael Parkhurst , New England Eddie Robinson , Houston Guillermo Barros Schelotto , Columbus Dwayne De Rosario , Houston (3) Christian Gómez , D.C. United (3) Shalrie Joseph , New England (2) Ben Olsen , D.C. United Juan Pablo Angel , Red Bulls Luciano Emílio , D.C. United 2008 [2] Jon Busch , Chicago Jimmy Conrad , Kansas City (4) Chad Marshall , Columbus Bakary Soumaré , Chicago Cuauhtémoc Blanco , Chicago Shalrie Joseph , New England (3) Sacha Kljestan , Chivas USA Robbie Rogers , Columbus Guillermo Barros Schelotto , Columbus (2) Kenny Cooper , Dallas Landon Donovan , LA Galaxy (2)2009 [2] Zach Thornton , Chivas USA (2) Geoff Cameron , Houston Wilman Conde , Chicago Chad Marshall , Columbus (2) Dwayne De Rosario , Toronto (4) Landon Donovan , LA Galaxy (3) Stuart Holden , Houston Shalrie Joseph , New England (4) Freddie Ljungberg , Seattle Conor Casey , Colorado Jeff Cunningham , Dallas (3)2010 [2] Donovan Ricketts , LA Galaxy Nat Borchers , Salt Lake Omar Gonzalez , LA Galaxy Jámison Olave , Salt Lake Dwayne De Rosario , Toronto (5) Landon Donovan , LA Galaxy (4) David Ferreira , Dallas Sébastien Le Toux , Philadelphia Javier Morales , Salt Lake Edson Buddle , LA Galaxy Chris Wondolowski , San Jose 2011 [2] Kasey Keller , Seattle Todd Dunivant , LA Galaxy Omar Gonzalez , LA Galaxy (2) Jámison Olave , Salt Lake (2) David Beckham , LA Galaxy Brad Davis , Houston Dwayne De Rosario , D.C. United (6) Landon Donovan , LA Galaxy (5) Brek Shea , Dallas Thierry Henry , Red Bulls Chris Wondolowski , San Jose (2)2012 [2] Jimmy Nielsen , Sporting KC Víctor Bernárdez , San Jose Matt Besler , Sporting KC Aurélien Collin , Sporting KC Osvaldo Alonso , Seattle Landon Donovan , LA Galaxy (6) Chris Pontius , D.C. United Graham Zusi , Sporting KC Thierry Henry , Red Bulls (2) Robbie Keane , LA Galaxy Chris Wondolowski , San Jose (3)2013 [2] Donovan Ricketts , Portland (2) Matt Besler , Sporting KC (2) José Gonçalves , New England Omar Gonzalez , LA Galaxy (3) Tim Cahill , Red Bulls Will Johnson , Portland Diego Valeri , Portland Graham Zusi , Sporting KC (2) Marco Di Vaio , Montreal Robbie Keane , LA Galaxy (2) Mike Magee , Chicago 2014 [2] Bill Hamid , D.C. United Bobby Boswell , D.C. United (2) Omar Gonzalez , LA Galaxy (4) Chad Marshall , Seattle (3) Landon Donovan , LA Galaxy (7) Thierry Henry , Red Bulls (3) Lee Nguyen , New England Diego Valeri , Portland (2) Robbie Keane , LA Galaxy (3) Obafemi Martins , Seattle Bradley Wright-Phillips , Red Bulls 2015 [2] Luis Robles , Red Bulls Laurent Ciman , Montreal Matt Hedges , Dallas Kendall Waston , Vancouver Fabián Castillo , Dallas Benny Feilhaber , Sporting KC Ethan Finlay , Columbus Dax McCarty , Red Bulls Sebastian Giovinco , Toronto Kei Kamara , Columbus Robbie Keane , LA Galaxy (4)2016 [2] Andre Blake , Philadelphia Matt Hedges , Dallas (2) Axel Sjöberg , Colorado Jelle Van Damme , LA Galaxy Mauro Díaz , Dallas Giovani dos Santos , LA Galaxy Sacha Kljestan , Red Bulls (2) Ignacio Piatti , Montreal Sebastian Giovinco , Toronto (2) David Villa , New York City Bradley Wright-Phillips , Red Bulls (2)2017 [2] Tim Melia , Sporting KC Justin Morrow , Toronto Ike Opara , Sporting KC Kendall Waston , Vancouver (2) Miguel Almirón , Atlanta Sebastian Giovinco , Toronto (3) Diego Valeri , Portland (3) Víctor Vázquez , Toronto Josef Martínez , Atlanta Nemanja Nikolić , Chicago David Villa , New York City (2)2018 [2] Zack Steffen , Columbus Kemar Lawrence , Red Bulls Aaron Long , Red Bulls Chad Marshall , Seattle (4) Luciano Acosta , D.C. United Miguel Almirón , Atlanta (2) Ignacio Piatti , Montreal (2) Carlos Vela , LAFC Zlatan Ibrahimović , LA Galaxy Josef Martínez , Atlanta (2) Wayne Rooney , D.C. United 2019 [2] Vito Mannone , Minnesota Ike Opara , Minnesota (2) Miles Robinson , Atlanta Walker Zimmerman , LAFC Eduard Atuesta , LAFC Carles Gil , New England Maximiliano Moralez , New York City Alejandro Pozuelo , Toronto Zlatan Ibrahimović , LA Galaxy (2) Josef Martínez , Atlanta (3) Carlos Vela , LAFC (2)2020 [2] Andre Blake , Philadelphia (2) Mark McKenzie , Philadelphia Jonathan Mensah , Columbus Walker Zimmerman , Nashville (2) Brenden Aaronson , Philadelphia Diego Chará , Portland Nicolás Lodeiro , Seattle Alejandro Pozuelo , Toronto (2) Jordan Morris , Seattle Diego Rossi , LAFC Raúl Ruidíaz , Seattle 2021 [4] Matt Turner , New England Yeimar Gómez , Seattle Miles Robinson , Atlanta (2) Walker Zimmerman , Nashville (3) Tajon Buchanan , New England Carles Gil , New England (2) Hany Mukhtar , Nashville João Paulo , Seattle Gustavo Bou , New England Taty Castellanos , New York City Raúl Ruidíaz , Seattle (2)2022 [5] Andre Blake , Philadelphia (3) Jakob Glesnes , Philadelphia Kai Wagner , Philadelphia Walker Zimmerman , Nashville (4) Luciano Acosta , Cincinnati (2) Sebastián Driussi , Austin Dániel Gazdag , Philadelphia Hany Mukhtar , Nashville (2) Jesús Ferreira , Dallas Brandon Vázquez , Cincinnati Carlos Vela , LAFC (3)2023 [6] Roman Bürki , St. Louis Matt Miazga , Cincinnati Tim Parker , St. Louis Walker Zimmerman , Nashville (5) Luciano Acosta , Cincinnati (3) Thiago Almada , Atlanta Héctor Herrera , Houston Hany Mukhtar , Nashville (3) Denis Bouanga , LAFC Giorgos Giakoumakis , Atlanta Cucho Hernández , Columbus