NACDA Directors' Cup

The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill won the award in its inaugural year, but then Stanford University won the Division I award for 25 straight years until the streak was broken in 2020–21 by the University of Texas. Texas repeated in 2022, Stanford regained the cup in 2023, and Texas won again in 2024.

In Division II, UC Davis won six of the first eight awards, but its athletic program moved to Division I in 2003 and Grand Valley State has won 16 of the 19 awards since as of 2024 (the title went unawarded for two years due to COVID-19). The only other current Division II member with an award is 1999 winner Adams State. All other Division II winners (Bakersfield, California Baptist, and Grand Canyon) are now members of Division I.

Williams College has had by far the most success in Division III, having won the Cup 22 of the 27 times it has been awarded for that division. The only other D-III member with more than one Cup is 2023 and 2024 winner Johns Hopkins.

The NAIA division was dominated by Simon Fraser University of British Columbia in its early years, but in 2002, SFU transferred most of its sports programs to Canada's college athletics federation, then known as Canadian Interuniversity Sport and now as U Sports. SFU left U Sports in 2011 and has since become a full member of NCAA Division II. From 2004–05 to 2011–12, Azusa Pacific University assumed the mantle at the NAIA level, winning eight consecutive championships before moving to NCAA Division II in the 2012–13 season. Oklahoma City University has been the most successful school since that year, with three Directors' Cups in the 2010s and four overall.

For two-year colleges, Iowa Central Community College has been the most successful school, winning five of the 10 titles.

• NCAA Division I: Counts top 19 sports at each school with the following breakdowns:^[5]
  • Four of which must be baseball, men's basketball, women's basketball and women's volleyball
  • The next highest 15 sports scored for each institution, regardless of gender, will be used in the standings (except men's water polo)^[a]
  • For FBS Football: the top 25 teams are awarded points based on their final rank in the Coaches Poll. 26th place is considered a tie between every non-ranked bowl winner, and the next available rank is considered a tie between every non-ranked bowl loser.
• NCAA Division II: Counts top 15 sports at each school with the following breakdowns:^[5]
  • Four of which must be baseball, men's basketball, women's basketball and women's volleyball
  • The next highest 11 sports scored for each institution, regardless of gender, will be used in the standings (except men's water polo)^[a]
• NCAA Division III: Counts top 18 sports at each school with the following breakdowns:^[5]
  • Four of which must be men's basketball, men's soccer, women's basketball and women's soccer
  • The next highest 14 sports scored for each institution, regardless of gender, will be used in the standings (except men's water polo)^[a]
• NAIA: Counts top 13 sports at each school with the following breakdowns:^[5]
  • Four of which must be men's basketball, men's soccer, women's basketball and women's volleyball
  • The next highest 9 sports scored for each institution, regardless of gender, will be used in the standings
• Junior/Community Colleges: The highest scoring institution in the NATYCAA Cup standings among the NJCAA Scholarship, NJCAA Non-Scholarship, and State Associations divisions will be declared the Directors' Cup winner.^[5]

If two teams have the same number of points at the end of the season, the tiebreaker is the number of national championships won. If still tied the next tiebreaker is the number of second-place finishes, then third-place finishes and so on until one team wins.^[5] The tiebreaker is only used for first place.

The scoring structure has been criticized for several reasons, especially due to the number of sports counted per division. Although the number of sports counted in the scoring is based on the average number of sports sponsored by a team in that division, certain schools offer many more or many fewer sports than that. For example, Stanford's dominance at the Division I level is partially attributable to them sponsoring 36 sports teams (of which 31 are NCAA sports), the most in Division I outside of the Ivy League, which does not grant athletic scholarships, and Ohio State, which sponsors 37 sports teams (of which 32 are NCAA sports). This gives Stanford more opportunities to win titles than most other schools, especially considering that some of the sports Stanford sponsors are not played by very many other schools (5 out of 31 have championship fields under 20 teams, and one [namely men's gymnastics] has fewer than 20 sponsoring schools), all but guaranteeing a substantial number of points for the few schools that do (NACDA awards significantly fewer points for teams that finish lower than fourth in sports with less competition, but the top four teams (except in 8-team and 4-team bracket sports) always receive 100, 90, 85, and 80 points respectively). It should be noted, however, that Ohio State, which sponsors teams in more NCAA sports than Stanford (5 of which, like Stanford, have championship fields under 20 teams) has never won the Cup (Ohio State has finished second 3 times, third twice, fourth 3 times, and in the top ten 7 more times).

Another common criticism is the fact that four sports are required to be counted despite some schools not sponsoring those sports. While every Division I school sponsors men's basketball, and all but two (The Citadel and VMI) sponsor women's basketball, a significant number of D-I schools do not sponsor the other two "mandatory counters" of baseball and women's volleyball. In the 2023–24 school year, 21 schools did not sponsor women's volleyball and 53 did not sponsor baseball, giving those schools an inherent disadvantage as they must count a sport for which they are guaranteed to receive no points.

Other reasons for criticism are over the way NACDA awards points in "National Collegiate" sports, which are sports where Division I, II, and III schools all compete directly against each other instead of being separated. The NCAA considers National Collegiate championships equivalent to Division I, therefore Division III schools are allowed to grant athletic scholarships in those sports, but NACDA counts points earned in National Collegiate competitions toward whatever division a team primarily competes in. Similarly, several otherwise Division III schools compete in Division I for men's ice hockey (despite Division III having its own ice hockey tournament), so there have been instances where two different Division III teams earn 100 points in the sport.^[6]

Multiple suggestions have been made to change the scoring system. Some of the most popular of these include making each sport worth a proportional number of points to the number of schools that compete in it, to get rid of the limit on the number of sports counted, then divide a school's total points by the number of sports it sponsors, and to count the median number of teams per division instead of the average (the median number of teams at a Division I school, for example, is 16, which is substantially lower than the 19 sports that are currently counted). However, NACDA has never seriously considered any of these suggestions.

From the creation of the award until the 2017–18 season the scoring was as follows:^[7]

• NCAA Division I: Counted up to 20 total sports at each school, with a maximum of 10 sports counted for each gender
• NCAA Division II: Counted up to 14 total sports at each school, with a maximum of 7 sports counted for each gender
• NCAA Division III: Counted up to 18 total sports at each school, with a maximum of 9 sports counted for each gender
• NAIA: Counted up to 12 total sports at each school, with a maximum of 6 sports counted for each gender
• Junior/Community Colleges: Same as current

• Results for years and schools shown in italics represent current standings and are not yet final.
• These results are for the "final" standings, calculated after spring sports end.

Stanford and Florida are the only schools to finish within the top 10 every season. Stanford has never finished below second.

Schools in italics no longer compete in the NAIA.

• List of NCAA schools with the most NCAA Division I championships
• List of sport awards
• Capital One Cup
• NATYCAA Cup

• Official website
• Learfield IMG College Directors' Cup Current Standings
• National Association of Collegiate Directors of Athletics
• "LEARFIELD Directors' Cup Previous Scoring" at National Association of Collegiate Directors of Athletics