1996 British Columbia general election

The 1996 British Columbia general election was the 36th provincial election in the Province of British Columbia, Canada. It was held to elect members of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. The election was called on April 30, 1996,[2] and held on May 28, 1996. Voter turnout was 59.1 per cent of all eligible voters. The election is notable for producing a "false-winner" outcome, rewarding a party that got second in the popular vote with a majority government.

1996 British Columbia general election

← 1991May 28, 19962001 →

75 seats of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia
38 seats were needed for a majority
Turnout71.50%[1] Decrease 3.57 pp
 First partySecond party
 
LeaderGlen ClarkGordon Campbell
PartyNew DemocraticLiberal
Leader since19961993
Leader's seatVancouver KingswayVancouver-Point Grey
Last election51 seats17 seats
Seats won3933
Seat changeDecrease12Increase16
Popular vote624,395661,929
Percentage39.4541.82
SwingDecrease1.26Increase8.58

 Third partyFourth party
 
Ref
PDA
LeaderJack WeisgerberGordon Wilson
PartyReformProgressive Democrat
Leader since19951993
Leader's seatPeace River SouthPowell River-Sunshine Coast
Last election0 seatspre-creation
Seats won21
Seat changeIncrease2Increase1
Popular vote146,73490,797
Percentage9.275.74
SwingIncrease9.09Increase5.74

Premier before election

Glen Clark
New Democratic

Premier after election

Glen Clark
New Democratic

New Democratic Party leader and provincial premier Mike Harcourt had resigned as the result of a fundraising scandal involving one of the members of his caucus. Glen Clark was chosen by the party to replace Harcourt. Clark led the party to a second majority government, defeating the Liberal Party of Gordon Campbell, who had become leader of the Liberal Party after Gordon Wilson had been forced out of the position because of his relationship with another Liberal member of the legislature, Judi Tyabji.

After Wilson was defeated by Campbell in the convention to choose a new leader, he and Tyabji left the Liberal Party to establish the Progressive Democratic Alliance. Wilson was able to win re-election, but Tyabji was not, who went down to defeat with all of the other candidates fielded by the new party.

The once-dominant Social Credit Party collapsed. It elected Grace McCarthy as its leader in 1993, but she was unable to make a bid to get into the legislature until 1994, when she lost a by-election in the longtime Socred stronghold of Matsqui. Soon afterward, four of its remaining six members defected to Reform BC, leaving Social Credit without official status in the legislature. One more seat was lost in a by-election, reducing the party's representation to one MLA, Cliff Serwa. Serwa retired before the election, however, leaving the party with no incumbents. Party leader Larry Gillanders withdrew from the race while the campaign was in progress, saying that all right-wing parties should unite to topple the ruling NDP. The Socreds won only 0.4% of the vote and were completely shut out of the legislature. While the party still nominally exists, it has never elected another MLA and even lost its registration from 2013 to 2016.

Reform BC held on to two of its four seats.

Although the Liberals won the largest share of the popular vote, most of their votes were wasted in the outer regions of the province, and it won only 8 seats in the Vancouver area. That allowed the NDP to win 6 more seats than the opposition Liberals, eking out a majority government. This was the last election to return an NDP majority until 2020, 24 years later.

Opinion polls

Evolution of voting intentions at provincial level
Polling firmLast day
of survey
SourceBCNDPBCLPRPBCPDABCSCOtherMESample
Election 1996May 28, 199639.4541.829.275.740.403.32
McIntyre & MustelMay 23, 1996[3]43.340.99.904.4630
Angus ReidMay 14, 1996[4]4041123.5800
McIntyre & MustelMay 11, 1996[5]4535.414.71.70.54.8516
Angus ReidMay 2, 1996[4][6]453317
McIntyre & MustelMay 1, 1996[7]4436161.61.44.2544
Election called (April 30, 1996)[2]
Evolution of voting intentions at provincial level
Polling firmLast day
of survey
SourceBCNDPBCLPRPBCPDABCSCOtherMESample
MarktrendApril 14, 1996[8]3832214.4503
Angus ReidMarch 12, 1996[9]403816314.0600
McIntyre & MustelMarch 1996[10]38382013295
MarkTrendFebruary 23, 1996[11]2938274.4502
ViewpointsJanuary 17, 1996[12]34.940.6202.51,600
MarkTrendJanuary 1996[12]283727
Glen Clark becomes leader of the NDP and Premier (February 22, 1996)
Angus ReidDecember 12, 1995[13]3540224.1605
Mike Harcourt announces resignation as Premier and leader of the NDP (November 15, 1995)|[14]
Angus ReidNovember 8, 1995[15]244922805
McIntyre & MustelMarch 1995[16]28472123284
Jack Weisgerber becomes leader of the BC Reform Party (January 15, 1995)[17]
MarkTrendDecember 1994[18]2541284.4500
McIntyre & MustelDecember 1994[19]314220
ViewpointsNovember 1994[20]3042222,000
McIntyre & MustelSeptember 1994[10]25412653304
Angus ReidSeptember 1994[21]3044197
McIntyre & MustelJune 5, 1994[22]213928754.5505
ViewpointsJune 1994[23]3039243
MarktrendJune 1994[23]2338343
Angus ReidMarch 1994[24]255370.4[25]104600
March 1994[26]25382110
Angus ReidDecember 1993[27]214714603
McIntyre & MustelDecember 1993[28]2049184.5502
PDA founded (December 5, 1993)
Angus ReidSeptember 1993[29]2648144600
Gordon Campbell becomes leader of the BC Liberals (September 11, 1993)
McIntyre & MustelSeptember 1993[30]275019[28]5
Angus ReidJune 1993[29]274222
Angus ReidMarch 10, 1993[31]4232174600
Angus ReidNovember 1992[31]3147
Angus Reid-Southam NewsAugust 31, 1992[32]3346168176
Angus Reid-Southam NewsJuly 1992[32]483211
Election 1991October 17, 199140.7133.250.18-24.271.59

Results

Elections to the 36th Legislative Assembly of British Columbia (1996)[33]
PartyLeaderCandidatesVotesSeats
#±%Change (pp)19911996±
New DemocraticGlen Clark75624,39529,004 39.45-1.26
 
51
39 / 75
12
LiberalGordon Campbell75661,929175,721 41.828.588.58
 
17
33 / 75
16
ReformJack Weisgerber75146,734143,701 9.279.099.09
 
2 / 75
2
Progressive DemocratGordon Wilson6690,79790,797 5.745.745.74
 
1 / 75
1
Social CreditLarry Gillanders386,276345,384 0.40-23.65
 
7
0 / 75
7
GreenStuart Parker7131,51118,861 1.991.131.13
 
Independent2310,067214 0.64-0.07
Family Coalition144,1502,840 0.260.17
Natural Law382,9192,919 0.18New
Libertarian172,0411,181 0.130.07
ConservativePeter B. Macdonald81,002576 0.060.03
Western Canada ConceptDoug Christie5374277 0.02-0.02
Common Sense, Community, FamilyRoss Ellis5291291 0.02New
Communist3218126 0.010.01
Total5131,582,704100.00%
Rejected ballots[1]9,95120,782
Turnout[1]1,592,65599,455 71.50%3.57
Registered voters[1]2,227,424238,370

MLAs elected

Synopsis of results

Results by riding - 1996 British Columbia general election[34]
RidingWinning partyTurnout
[a 1]
Votes[a 2]
Name1991PartyVotesShareMargin
#
Margin
%
NDPLibRefPDGrnSCFCPNLPIndOthTotal
 
AbbotsfordSCLib10,99850.24%5,59325.55%69.25%5,40510,9984,0861,12627421,889
AlberniNDPNDP7,39852.01%2,29916.16%73.32%7,3985,099823578195587214,223
Bulkley Valley-StikineNDPNDP4,77937.02%1,0538.16%71.05%4,7793,7263,47362415115512,908
Burnaby-EdmondsNDPNDP9,91246.45%1,1425.35%70.63%9,9128,7701,0081,0673871207721,341
Burnaby NorthNDPNDP8,92645.47%7663.90%72.70%8,9268,1601,081976395623119,631
Burnaby-WillingdonNDPNDP10,50145.54%8233.57%71.73%10,5019,6789991,1614587419023,061
Cariboo NorthNDPLib5,53340.87%3532.61%70.05%5,1805,5332,5611689713,539
Cariboo SouthNDPNDP6,37241.45%3222.09%70.88%6,3726,0502,68426715,373
ChilliwackLibLib9,27337.90%3,28413.42%68.57%5,9899,2733,2372325,73624,467
Columbia River-RevelstokeNDPNDP6,26442.52%1,0927.41%71.04%6,2645,1722,6872822705814,733
Comox ValleyNDPNDP13,23042.76%2,5098.11%72.86%13,23010,7213,4511,0391,29639880430,939
Coquitlam-MaillardvilleNDPNDP10,81245.91%1,3725.83%72.33%10,8129,4401,4341,28913312332023,551
Cowichan-LadysmithNDPNDP12,24949.85%4,46618.18%73.97%12,2497,7832,4341,45964524,570
Delta NorthNDPLib9,30545.50%6483.17%74.88%8,6579,3057551,38534720,449
Delta SouthLibLib13,41558.78%7,43132.56%74.55%5,98413,4151,3711,21533320030422,822
Esquimalt-MetchosinNDPNDP13,83359.54%7,06330.40%68.16%13,8336,7701,17992137660583523,232
Fort Langley-AldergroveLibLib12,00547.30%4,63618.26%76.09%7,36912,0053,4841,73747231625,383
KamloopsNDPNDP10,13544.30%8623.77%69.56%10,1359,2731,7211,24150822,878
Kamloops-North ThompsonNDPLib7,31343.43%3682.19%72.65%6,9457,3131,71040146816,837
KootenayNDPNDP6,39838.59%5113.08%68.15%6,3985,8873,71836321516,581
LangleyLibLib9,27746.62%3,48217.50%73.19%5,7959,2773,2241,19526214819,901
Malahat-Juan de FucaNDPNDP10,68648.63%3,13014.24%72.91%10,6867,5561,8871,061601988421,973
Maple Ridge-Pitt MeadowsNDPNDP12,94646.07%1,9867.07%73.30%12,94610,9601,4702,0114649015828,099
MatsquiSCLib10,90350.81%5,55425.88%68.41%5,34910,9034,40521638519921,457
Mission-KentNDPNDP8,23244.16%1,1206.01%70.92%8,2327,1121,6181,24332411318,642
NanaimoNDPNDP11,21048.75%3,53815.39%69.79%11,2107,6721,8671,33748631111322,996
Nelson-CrestonNDPNDP9,17944.90%2,74513.43%75.20%9,1796,4342,1142,2823607320,442
New WestminsterNDPNDP10,41846.69%1,8278.19%70.41%10,4188,5911,4461,12148810714222,313
North CoastNDPNDP7,29864.82%4,39939.07%63.33%7,2982,89983023211,259
North IslandNDPNDP8,38545.80%1,6048.76%69.55%8,3856,7811,77688747918,308
North Vancouver-LonsdaleNDPLib9,32546.37%2,17410.81%71.16%7,1519,3251,2411,7364179314920,112
North Vancouver-SeymourLibLib14,16556.35%7,48929.79%76.91%6,67614,1651,7371,713645105445425,139
Oak Bay-Gordon HeadNDPLib12,34046.59%6402.42%79.49%11,70012,34067593756648564711826,487
Okanagan-BoundaryNDPLib7,01138.35%270.15%75.05%6,9847,0112,81077535618316318,282
Okanagan EastLibLib9,38238.37%2,95012.06%70.24%5,1769,3823,1166,43234724,453
Okanagan-PentictonNDPLib10,66143.07%1,5696.34%73.41%9,09210,6612,9761,44446411324,750
Okanagan-VernonSCLib9,77639.06%2,2799.11%71.03%7,4979,7765,3561,83933422725,029
Okanagan WestSCLib15,57546.00%7,29421.54%71.02%8,28115,5754,8584,22551939933,857
Parksville-QualicumNDPLib13,45941.19%4831.48%77.12%12,97613,4593,9551,6694221108132,672
Peace River NorthSCRef5,29948.41%2,16219.75%60.49%1,9753,1375,29916924012510,945
Peace River SouthSCRef3,90131.89%1231.01%62.60%3,7783,7743,90118314545212,233
Port CoquitlamNDPNDP14,76746.37%1,4574.58%73.48%14,76713,3101,3351,78941712410231,844
Port Moody-Burnaby MountainNDPLib10,27244.73%4682.04%73.40%9,80410,2721,0391,40844122,964
Powell River-Sunshine CoastLibPD10,83349.05%4,74521.49%75.37%6,0883,91167710,8335185722,084
Prince George-Mount RobsonNDPNDP4,71340.67%9498.19%63.84%4,7133,7642,07678824711,588
Prince George NorthNDPNDP5,83739.58%9146.20%66.75%5,8374,9232,43089117349514,749
Prince George-OminecaSCLib5,51436.88%3082.06%67.79%5,2065,5142,9981,02320914,950
Richmond CentreLibLib9,92555.52%4,20223.51%68.67%5,7239,925614996235154386512617,876
Richmond EastLibLib10,20555.60%4,44224.20%71.62%5,76310,2057921,093235139438318,353
Richmond-StevestonLibLib9,64356.65%4,60227.04%74.36%5,0419,64355691918888384509917,022
Rossland-TrailNDPNDP8,63550.74%2,71215.94%74.99%8,6355,9231,36666043417,018
Saanich North and the IslandsLibLib13,37447.57%2,82810.06%77.89%10,54613,3741,6271,533898726328,113
Saanich SouthNDPNDP11,39446.11%5272.13%77.16%11,39410,8676761,1983438614424,708
ShuswapNDPLib8,59634.55%7272.92%72.79%7,8698,5965,6171,3252372211,01424,879
SkeenaNDPNDP5,35340.34%6354.79%70.72%5,3534,7182,74420524913,269
Surrey-CloverdaleLibLib14,29748.27%5,46618.46%74.75%8,83114,2972,6902,41736630670929,616
Surrey-Green TimbersNDPNDP10,27850.11%3,34816.32%69.40%10,2786,9301,1831,1502281142553210124120,512
Surrey-NewtonNDPNDP13,96949.54%4,18114.83%71.33%13,9699,7881,2441,8413401745774821728,198
Surrey-WhalleyNDPNDP7,39650.14%2,82019.12%65.38%7,3964,5761,302968243115708214,752
Surrey-White RockLibLib18,03958.04%9,82431.61%75.89%8,21518,0392,5191,11067722629531,081
Vancouver-BurrardNDPNDP10,64649.70%2,67112.47%62.68%10,6467,9756711,0145639345821,420
Vancouver-FraserviewNDPNDP8,77445.97%3801.99%71.94%8,7748,394[a 3]6438152251775719,085
Vancouver-HastingsNDPNDP9,89454.01%3,54919.37%67.96%9,8946,3455688244861376418,318
Vancouver-KensingtonNDPNDP9,49650.74%1,88810.09%70.25%9,4967,60847253734913511918,716
Vancouver-KingswayNDPNDP10,52555.46%3,52818.59%71.07%10,5256,9973675182647565699818,978
Vancouver-LangaraLibLib11,03860.20%5,52330.12%68.66%5,51511,0385198393378918,337
Vancouver-Little MountainNDPLib12,03650.25%2,64611.05%68.32%9,39012,0364891,06271485829623,954
Vancouver-Mount PleasantNDPNDP11,15564.05%6,91239.69%60.50%11,1554,2433545847598611412117,416
Vancouver-Point GreyNDPLib12,63748.86%1,5636.04%71.03%11,07412,63740685768362767025,865
Vancouver-QuilchenaLibLib15,50968.68%10,53246.64%75.71%4,97715,509495827627915722,583
Victoria-Beacon HillNDPNDP11,96052.51%4,32418.98%68.17%11,9607,6366541,0931,00896647319422,778
Victoria-HillsideNDPNDP11,58553.32%4,72321.74%67.53%11,5856,8629791,2277909718821,728
West Vancouver-CapilanoLibLib16,67571.29%13,18956.38%76.63%3,48616,6751,3261,182461174474023,391
West Vancouver-GaribaldiLibLib12,32657.17%6,03828.00%73.03%6,28812,3261,430693532983615921,562
Yale-LillooetNDPNDP7,08041.06%1,1686.77%72.21%7,0805,9123,41970612417,241
  = Open seat
  = turnout is above provincial average
  = winning candidate was in previous Legislature
  = Incumbent had switched allegiance
  = Previously incumbent in another riding
  = Not incumbent; was previously elected to the Legislature
  = Incumbency arose from by-election gain
  = other incumbents renominated
  = previously an MP in the House of Commons of Canada
  = Multiple candidates

Summary analysis

Party candidates in 2nd place[35]
Party in 1st placeParty in 2nd placeTotal
NDPLibPD
New Democratic3939
Liberal32133
Reform112
Progressive Democrat11
Total3440175
Candidates ranked 1st to 5th place, by party[35]
Parties1st2nd3rd4th5th
 New Democratic39342
 Liberal33402
 Reform244245
 Progressive Democrat1124373
 Green2952
 Independent14
 Social Credit42
 Family Coalition15
 Libertarian2

Seats changing hands

Of the 75 seats, 23 were open, of which 21 had members who chose not to stand for reelection, and two arose from MLAs campaigning in another riding. Voters in only 20 seats changed allegiance from the previous election in 1991:

Resulting composition of the 36th Legislative Assembly of British Columbia
SourceParty
NDPLibRefPDTotal
Seats retainedIncumbents returned28836
Open seats held11516
Ouster of incumbents changing affiliation33
Seats changing handsIncumbents defeated88
Open seats gained - new MLAs55
Open seats gained - taken by MLAs previously incumbent in another riding22
Byelection gains held22
Incumbents changing allegiance213
Total39332175

References

Further reading