143rd New York State Legislature

The 143rd New York State Legislature, consisting of the New York State Senate and the New York State Assembly, met from January 7 to September 1920, during the second year of Al Smith's governorship, in Albany.

143rd New York State Legislature
142nd 144th
The facade of the New York State Capitol building in bright daylight
Overview
Legislative bodyNew York State Legislature
JurisdictionNew York, United States
TermJanuary 1 – December 31, 1920
Senate
Members51
PresidentLt. Gov. Harry C. Walker (D)
Temporary PresidentJ. Henry Walters (R)
Party controlRepublican (30–21)
Assembly
Members150
SpeakerThaddeus C. Sweet (R)
Party controlRepublican (110–35–5)
Sessions
1stJanuary 7 – April 25, 1920
2ndSeptember 20 – 24?, 1920

Background

Under the provisions of the New York Constitution of 1894, re-apportioned in 1917, 51 Senators and 150 assemblymen were elected in single-seat districts; senators for a two-year term, assemblymen for a one-year term. The senatorial districts consisted either of one or more entire counties; or a contiguous area within a single county. The counties which were divided into more than one senatorial district were New York (nine districts), Kings (eight), Bronx (three), Erie (three), Monroe (two), Queens (two) and Westchester (two). The Assembly districts were made up of contiguous area, all within the same county.

At this time there were two major political parties: the Republican Party and the Democratic Party. The Socialist Party also nominated tickets.

Elections

The New York state election, 1919, was held on November 4. No statewide elective offices were up for election. Two women were elected to the State Assembly: Elizabeth V. Gillette (Dem.), a physician, of Schenectady; and Marguerite L. Smith (Rep.), an athletics teacher, of Harlem.

Sessions

The Legislature met for the regular session at the State Capitol in Albany on January 7, 1920. Thaddeus C. Sweet (R) was re-elected Speaker.

At the beginning of the session, the five Socialist assemblymen were suspended by Speaker Sweet, pending a trial before the Assembly Committee on the Judiciary to determine whether they were fit to take their seats. Charles Evans Hughes (Rep.) and Governor Al Smith (Dem.) condemned Speaker Sweet and the Republican majority for taking this course of action.[1]

On March 30, a majority of 7 members of the 13-member Judiciary Committee recommended the expulsion the five Socialists. Minority reports recommended the seating of all or part of the Socialist assemblymen.[2]

In the early morning of April 1, the five Socialist assemblymen were expelled.[3]

The Legislature adjourned at 2 a.m. on Sunday morning, April 25, after a session of 37 hours.[4] During this last session, Marguerite L. Smith occupied for about half an hour the Speaker's chair.[5]

On August 12, Gov. Al Smith called a special session of the Legislature for September 20, and ordered special elections to be held on September 16 to fill the vacancies caused by the expulsion of the Socialist members. The session was called to consider the housing situation in New York City.[6]

On September 16, all five Socialists were re-elected to the Assembly.

The Legislature met for a special session at the State Capitol in Albany on September 20, 1920.[7]

On September 21, Claessens, Solomon and Waldman were again expelled, while DeWitt and Orr were permitted by a majority vote to take their seats. However, DeWitt and Orr resigned their seats in protest against the ouster of their three comrades.[8]

State Senate

Districts

Members

The asterisk (*) denotes members of the previous Legislature who continued in office as members of this Legislature.

DistrictSenatorPartyNotes
1stGeorge L. Thompson*Republican
2ndJohn L. KarleRepublicanelected to fill vacancy, in place of Frank F. Adel
3rdPeter J. McGarry*Democrat
4thKenneth F. Sutherland*Democrat
5thDaniel F. Farrell*Democrat
6thLoring M. Black Jr.*Democrat
7thCharles C. Lockwood*Republican
8thAlvah W. Burlingame Jr.*Republican
9thCharles E. Russell*Democrat
10thJeremiah F. Twomey*Democrat
11thDaniel J. Carroll*Democrat
12thJimmy Walker*DemocratMinority Leader
13thJohn J. Boylan*Democrat
14thBernard Downing*Democrat
15thAbraham Kaplan*Democrat
16thJoseph D. KellyDemocratelected to fill vacancy, in place of James A. Foley
17thJulius Miller*Democrat
18thSalvatore A. Cotillo*Democrat
19thEdward J. Dowling*Democrat
20thWilliam C. Dodge*Democrat
21stHenry G. Schackno*Democrat
22ndPeter A. Abeles*Republican
23rdJohn J. Dunnigan*Democrat
24thJohn A. Lynch*Democrat
25thGeorge T. Burling*Republican
26thWalter W. Law Jr.*Republican
27thCaleb H. Baumes*Republican
28thJames E. Towner*Republican
29thCharles W. Walton*Republican
30thHenry M. Sage*Republican
31stJohn J. Mackrell*Democrat
32ndJames W. Yelverton*Republican
33rdMortimer Y. Ferris*Republican
34thN. Monroe Marshall*Republicanon November 2, 1920, elected New York State Treasurer
35thBurt Z. Kasson*Republican
36thFrederick M. Davenport*Republican
37thFred B. Pitcher*Republican
38thJ. Henry Walters*RepublicanPresident pro tempore
39thAdon P. Brown*RepublicanChairman of Agriculture
40thClayton R. Lusk*Republican
41stSeymour Lowman*Republican
42ndCharles J. Hewitt*Republican
43rdWilliam A. Carson*Republican
44thJohn Knight*Republican
45thJames L. Whitley*Republican
46thJohn B. Mullan*Republican
47thGeorge F. Thompson*Republican
48thvacantRoss Graves resigned on December 27, 1919
Parton SwiftRepublicanelected to fill vacancy on February 3, 1920[9]
49thSamuel J. Ramsperger*Democrat
50thLeonard W. H. Gibbs*Republican
51stJ. Samuel Fowler*Republican

Employees

  • Clerk: Ernest A. Fay
  • Sergeant-at-Arms:
  • Assistant Sergeant-at-Arms:
  • Principal Doorkeeper:
  • First Assistant Doorkeeper:
  • Stenographer:

State Assembly

Note: For brevity, the chairmanships omit the words "...the Committee on (the)..."

Assemblymen

DistrictAssemblymenPartyNotes
Albany1stEdgar C. CampbellRepublican
2ndCharles F. MossRepublican
3rdFrank L. WiswallRepublican
AlleganyWilliam Duke Jr.*Republican
Bronx1stAlbert H. HendersonDemocrat
2ndEdward J. Flynn*Democrat
3rd(Samuel A. DeWitt)Socialistsuspended on January 7; expelled on April 1; elected to
fill vacancy on September 16, resigned on September 21
4th(Samuel Orr)Socialistsuspended on January 7; expelled on April 1; elected to
fill vacancy on September 16, resigned on September 21
5thWilliam S. Evans*Democrat
6thThomas J. McDonald*Democrat
7thJoseph V. McKee*Democrat
8thJ. Fairfax McLaughlin*Democrat
Broome1stEdmund B. Jenks*Republican
2ndForman E. Whitcomb*Republican
CattaraugusDeHart H. Ames*Republican
CayugaL. Ford Hager*Republican
Chautauqua1stHermes L. Ames*Republicandied on August 23, 1920
2ndJoseph A. McGinnies*Republican
ChemungJohn J. Richford*Republican
ChenangoBert Lord*Republican
ClintonCharles M. HarringtonRepublican
ColumbiaRansom H. GillettRepublican
CortlandIrving F. Rice*Republican
DelawareLincoln R. Long*Republican
Dutchess1stJ. Griswold Webb*Republican
2ndFrank L. Gardner*Republican
Erie1stGeorge E. D. Brady*Republican
2ndJohn W. Slacer*Republican
3rdAugust SeelbachRepublican
4thAndrew T. Beasley*Democrat
5thAlexander A. Patrzykowski*Democrat
6thGeorge H. Rowe*Republican
7thHerbert A. Zimmerman*Republican
8thNelson W. Cheney*Republican
EssexRaymond T. Kenyon*Republican
FranklinWarren T. Thayer*Republican
Fulton and HamiltonEberly Hutchinson*Republican
GeneseeCharles P. Miller*Republican
GreeneFrank G. JacobsRepublican
HerkimerEdward O. Davies*Republican
JeffersonH. Edmund Machold*Republican
Kings1stJohn J. Griffith*Democrat
2ndJames J. MullenRepublican
3rdFrank J. Taylor*Democrat
4thPeter A. McArdle*Democrat
5thJames H. Caulfield Jr.*RepublicanChairman of Commerce and Navigation
6thHarry DiminRepublican
7thJohn J. Kelly*Democrat
8thMichael J. ReillyDemocrat
9thJames T. CarrollRepublican
10thLeo V. DohertyRepublican
11thJames F. BlyRepublican
12thWilliam T. SimpsonRepublican
13thGeorge W. LindsayDemocrat
14thJoseph Lentol*Democrat
15thJohn J. McLoughlinDemocrat
16thHarvey J. RossRepublican
17thFrederick A. Wells*RepublicanChairman of Military Affairs
18thTheodore StittRepublican
19thJohn DamicoRepublican
20thJohn O. GemplerRepublican
21stWarren I. LeeRepublican
22ndGeorge U. ForbellRepublican
23rd(Charles Solomon)*Socialistsuspended on January 7; expelled on April 1; elected to
fill vacancy on September 16, expelled on September 21
LewisFrederick S. Easton Jr.Democrat
LivingstonGeorge F. Wheelock*Republican
MadisonMorell E. Tallett*Republican
Monroe1stJames A. Harris*Republican
2ndSimon L. Adler*RepublicanMajority Leader
3rdHarry B. Crowley*Republican
4thFrank Dobson*Republican
5thFranklin W. Judson*Republican
MontgomeryAlton A. Walrath*Republican
Nassau1stThomas A. McWhinney*Republican
2ndTheodore Roosevelt Jr.Republican
New York1stPeter J. Hamill*Democrat
2ndCaesar B. F. Barra*Democrat
3rdThomas F. BurchillDemocrat
4thSamuel Dickstein*Democrat
5thCharles D. Donohue*DemocratMinority Leader
6thSol Ullman*Republican
7thNoel B. FoxRepublican
8th(Louis Waldman)Socialistsuspended on January 7; expelled on April 1; elected to
fill vacancy on September 16, expelled on September 21
9thMartin BourkeRepublican
10thWilliam W. Pellet*Republican
11thWilliam C. Amos*Republican
12thMartin G. McCue*Democrat
13thRobert B. WallaceRepublican
14thEdward F. HealeyDemocrat
15thJoseph Steinberg*Republican
16thMaurice Bloch*Democrat
17th(August Claessens)*Socialistsuspended on January 7; expelled on April 1; elected to
fill vacancy on September 16, expelled on September 21
18thOwen M. Kiernan*Democrat
19thMarguerite L. SmithRepublican
20thLouis A. CuvillierDemocrat
21stJohn Clifford Hawkins*Republican
22ndOscar J. SmithRepublican
23rdGeorge N. JesseRepublican
Niagara1stDavid E. JefferyRepublican
2ndAlan V. ParkerRepublican
Oneida1stHartwell W. Booth*Republican
2ndLouis M. Martin*RepublicanChairman of Judiciary
3rdChauncey J. WilliamsRepublican
Onondaga1stManuel J. Soule*Republican
2ndGardner J. Chamberlin*Republican
3rdGeorge R. Fearon*RepublicanChairman of Affairs of Cities
OntarioGeorge M. Tyler*Republican
Orange1stArthur E. BrundageRepublican
2ndCharles L. Mead*Republican
OrleansFrank H. Lattin*Republican
OswegoThaddeus C. Sweet*Republicanre-elected Speaker
OtsegoAllen J. Bloomfield*Republican
PutnamJohn P. Donohoe*Republican
Queens1stPeter A. Leininger*Democrat
2ndBernard Schwab*Democrat
3rdEdward J. NearyRepublican
4thNicholas M. PetteRepublican
5thRalph HalpernRepublican
6thHenry BaumRepublican
Rensselaer1stHugh C. MorrisseyRepublican
2ndArthur Cowee*Republican
Richmond1stThomas F. CosgroveDemocrat
2ndGeorge P. ReynaudDemocrat
RocklandGordon H. Peck*Republican
St. Lawrence1stFrank L. Seaker*Republican
2ndEdward A. Everett*Republican
SaratogaClarence C. Smith*Republican
Schenectady1stHarold E. BlodgettRepublican
2ndElizabeth V. GilletteDemocrat
SchoharieJared Van Wagenen Jr.Democrat
SchuylerClarence W. HausnerRepublican
SenecaGeorge A. DobsonRepublican
Steuben1stErnest E. ColeRepublican
2ndDelevan C. Hunter*Republican
Suffolk1stJohn G. Downs*Republican
2ndWilliam G. CarrollDemocrat
SullivanGuernsey T. CrossDemocrat
TiogaDaniel P. Witter*Republican
TompkinsCasper Fenner*Republican
UlsterSimon B. Van WagenenRepublican
WarrenStewart MacFarlandRepublican
WashingtonEugene R. Norton*Republican
WayneCharles H. BettsRepublican
Westchester1stThomas Channing MooreRepublican
2ndWalter W. Westall*Republican
3rdEdward J. Wilson*Republican
4thMitchell A. Trahan Jr.Republican
5thGeorge Blakely*Republican
WyomingBert P. Gage*Republican
YatesJames M. Lown*Republican

Employees

Notes

Sources